future Red Dead story directions
Members debate whether a new Red Dead should depict the Blackwater massacre, concluding a fresh protagonist or theme works better.
- Depicting the Blackwater massacre as the ending would restrict post-game exploration since the gang is immediately forced to flee into the mountains
- Playing as the Callander brothers is suggested as a way to cover the events preceding the second game
- Continuing the Van der Linde storyline risks tiring out the narrative since their history is already largely revealed through in-game dialogue
- A new entry could focus on rebellion or revolution rather than redemption, highlighting another group resisting the end of the Wild West era


