balanced vs random ranked dice
Players argue whether ranked Catan should introduce pity dice mechanics to prevent extreme roll outliers or keep purely random dice.
- A player proposes a hybrid system with 85% random and 15% balancing dice to prevent extreme outliers like zero 5s rolling all game
- Others defend purely random dice in ranked, noting that rare statistical anomalies are natural across high game volumes
- Colonist already offers balanced dice as an option for casual matches
- Skill in Catan involves mitigating uncontrollable randomness and consistently positioning for winning odds over many games


