legitimacy of Silvan Elf kings
Members debate whether Oropher and Amdir held legitimate kingship over Silvan realms or required descent from Thingol.
- One view argues Elven kingship requires descent from high kings like Thingol, making Oropher and Amdir pretenders
- Others argue legitimacy comes from founding new realms and acceptance by the Silvan population rather than clan-wide claims
- Sindar who migrated east sought simpler lives and independence rather than genuine hatred toward Gil-galad
- Oropher and Amdir's reckless refusal to coordinate during the Last Alliance at Dagorlad stemmed from pride
- Continued rule by heirs like Thranduil and Amroth without challenge reinforces their established political legitimacy


